Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
media_and_the_public [2015/12/06 01:48]
nathanairplane [Leaks, repression, censorship]
media_and_the_public [2021/01/02 02:39] (current)
Line 31: Line 31:
     * Adherence to standard op-ed or press release format     * Adherence to standard op-ed or press release format
     * Correct length, spelling, and grammar     * Correct length, spelling, and grammar
 +    * Sophisticated engagement with at least one of the readings in the course so far
   * Responsible advocacy:   * Responsible advocacy:
     * Clarity of argument     * Clarity of argument
Line 40: Line 41:
 ### Final project ### Final project
  
-For this assignment, draft, revise, and publish an analysis of a media campaign of your choosing, individually or as part of a group. Written projects should be between 1,400-1,600 words, and videos between 4-6 minutes. Standards for other media should be agreed on with the instructor.+For this assignment, draft, revise, and publish an analysis of a media campaign of your choosing, individually or as part of a group. Your analysis should be written so as to have an effect for its intended audience. Written projects should be between 1,400-1,600 words, and videos between 4-6 minutes. Standards for other media should be agreed on with the instructor.
  
 Campaigns might include, for instance: an Internet meme, a politician'​s slogan, an iconic advertisement,​ a university marketing drive, a blacklisting effort, a struggle for political rights. Campaigns might include, for instance: an Internet meme, a politician'​s slogan, an iconic advertisement,​ a university marketing drive, a blacklisting effort, a struggle for political rights.
Line 49: Line 50:
  
   * A carefully documented and persuasive argument about the campaign, grounded in an analysis of its planning, execution, effectiveness,​ use of media, and relevant publics   * A carefully documented and persuasive argument about the campaign, grounded in an analysis of its planning, execution, effectiveness,​ use of media, and relevant publics
-  * Engagement with some key themes, readings, and discussions in the course, such as democracy, economic models, ethics, and perspective +  * Engagement with key themes, readings, and discussions in the course, such as democracy, economic models, ethics, and perspective, including reference to at least two texts on the syllabus 
-  * Adherence to the topic, medium, and scope agreed on with the instructor +  * Adherence to the topic, medium, and scope agreed on with the instructor; the medium, intended audience, and objective of the piece should be clear 
-  * Excellence in execution, including grammar, spelling, AP Style (if written), visual clarity, and other standards relevant to the medium+  * Excellence in execution, including grammar, spelling, AP Style (if written), visual clarity, and other standards relevant to the medium; improvement from the first draft should be evident in the final
  
 ## Evaluation ## Evaluation
Line 60: Line 61:
   * 25 points - quality and persistence of participation in online discussions   * 25 points - quality and persistence of participation in online discussions
   * 20 points - midterm project:   * 20 points - midterm project:
-    * 10 points - first draft and participation in peer review +    * points - first draft and  
-    * 10 points - revision ​with evidence of improvement+    * 3 points - participation in peer review 
 +    * 10 points - final draft with
   * 30 points - final project:   * 30 points - final project:
-    * 10 points - first draft and participation in peer review +    * 2 points - approved proposal 
-    * 20 points - revision with evidence of improvement+    * 5 points - first draft 
 +    * 3 points - participation in peer review 
 +    * 20 points - final draft
  
-Each student is allotted 3 unexcused absences. After that, absences without a documented excuse will result in points detracted from the class participation grade.+Each student is allotted 3 unexcused absences. After that, absences without a documented excuse will result in points detracted from the class participation grade.
  
 Badges, worth 1 extra point, will be awarded at the conclusion of each module: Badges, worth 1 extra point, will be awarded at the conclusion of each module:
Line 76: Line 80:
  
 There is a limit of one badge per person per week. There is a limit of one badge per person per week.
 +
 +### Final grades
 +
 +Based on the stated point structure, grades will be awarded as follows: A (94-100), A- (90-93), B+ (87-89), B (83-86), B- (80-82), C+ (77-79), C (73-76), C- (70-72), D+ (67-69), D (63-66), D- (60-62), F (0-59).
  
 ## Units ## Units
Line 96: Line 104:
  
   * Robert A. Dahl, _On Democracy_ (Yale University Press, 1998)   * Robert A. Dahl, _On Democracy_ (Yale University Press, 1998)
 +
  
 ### Private and publics ### Private and publics
  
-*   ​Hannah Arendt, “[The Private and the Public](http://​frontdeskapparatus.com/​files/​arendt.pdf),​” from __The Human Condition__ (1958) 
 *   ​Michael Warner, "​[Publics and Counterpublics](http://​muse.jhu.edu/​journals/​pc/​summary/​v014/​14.1warner.html),"​ _Public Culture 14_, no. 1 (2002) *   ​Michael Warner, "​[Publics and Counterpublics](http://​muse.jhu.edu/​journals/​pc/​summary/​v014/​14.1warner.html),"​ _Public Culture 14_, no. 1 (2002)
 *   Adam Curtis, _[The Century of the Self](http://​topdocumentaryfilms.com/​the-century-of-the-self/​)_ (2002) *   Adam Curtis, _[The Century of the Self](http://​topdocumentaryfilms.com/​the-century-of-the-self/​)_ (2002)
  
 On the latter, watch at least the first two episodes, and after that only as far as you like. It's over-long and repetitive, but well-calculated to blow your mind. On the latter, watch at least the first two episodes, and after that only as far as you like. It's over-long and repetitive, but well-calculated to blow your mind.
 +
  
 ### Objectivity and perspective ### Objectivity and perspective
  
-  Robert Kaplan, "[The Origins of Objectivity in American Journalism](https://​www.academia.edu/​2235733/​The_Origins_of_Objectivity_in_American_Journalism),"​ in Stuart Allen (ed.), _The Routledge Companion to News and Journalism_ (Routledge, 2010) +  ​Robert Kaplan, "[The Origins of Objectivity in American Journalism](https://​www.academia.edu/​2235733/​The_Origins_of_Objectivity_in_American_Journalism),"​ in Stuart Allen (ed.), _The Routledge Companion to News and Journalism_ (Routledge, 2010) 
-  ​Donna Haraway, "​[Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of   +  * Donna Haraway, "​[Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective](http://​www.staff.amu.edu.pl/​~ewa/​Haraway,​%20Situated%20Knowledges.pdf),"​ _Feminist Studies_ 14, no. 3\. (1988) 
-    ​Partial Perspective](http://​www.staff.amu.edu.pl/​~ewa/​Haraway,​%20Situated%20Knowledges.pdf),"​ _Feminist Studies_ 14, no. 3\. (1988) +  * Gene Demby, "[How Black Reporters Report on Black Death](http://​www.npr.org/​sections/​codeswitch/​2015/​08/​20/​432590298/​how-black-reporters-report-on-black-death),"​ _Code Switch_ (August 20, 2015) 
-  ​Gene Demby, "[How Black Reporters Report on Black Death](http://​www.npr.org/​sections/​codeswitch/​2015/​08/​20/​432590298/​how-black-reporters-report-on-black-death),"​ _Code Switch_ (August 20, 2015) +  * Mónica Guzmán, "​[Journalism and the Self-Informing Public](https://​vimeo.com/​88488324),"​ Reynolds School of Journalism (March 7, 2014) 
-  ​Mónica Guzmán, "​[Journalism and the Self-Informing Public](https://​vimeo.com/​88488324),"​ Reynolds School of Journalism (March 7, 2014)+
  
 ### Media ethics ### Media ethics
- 
-On journalism, including our very own [Paul Voakes](http://​www.colorado.edu/​cmci/​about-college/​department-chairs/​paul-s-voakes):​ 
- 
-*   Paul S. Voakes, "​[Rights,​ Wrongs, and Responsibilities:​ Law and Ethics in the Newsroom](http://​www.tandfonline.com/​doi/​abs/​10.1207/​S15327728JMME1501_4),"​ _Journal of Mass Media Ethics_ 15, no. 1 (2000) 
-*   danah boyd and Kelly McBride, "[The Destabilizing Force of Fear](http://​www.danah.org/​papers/​2013/​DestabilizingFear-DRAFT.pdf),"​ in Kelly McBride and Tom Rosentiel (eds.), _The New Ethics of Journalism_ (CQ Press, 2013) 
  
 On public relations and advocacy: On public relations and advocacy:
  
-  Sherry Baker, “{{:​src:​baker-pr_ethics.pdf|The Ethics of Advocacy: Moral Reasoning in the Practice of Public Relations}},​” in Wilkins and Christians (eds.), _The Handbook of Mass Media Ethics_ (New York: Routledge. 2009), pp. 115-129.+  ​Sherry Baker, “{{:​src:​baker-pr_ethics.pdf|The Ethics of Advocacy: Moral Reasoning in the Practice of Public Relations}},​” in Wilkins and Christians (eds.), _The Handbook of Mass Media Ethics_ (New York: Routledge. 2009), pp. 115-129
 + 
 +**Need a strong reading on journalistic ethics.** Perhaps from _The New Ethics of Journalism: Principles for the 21st Century_.
  
-Often debates about journalistic ethics take on a very political character.+  * danah boyd and Kelly McBride, "[The Destabilizing Force of Fear](http://​www.danah.org/​papers/​2013/​DestabilizingFear-DRAFT.pdf),"​ in Kelly McBride and Tom Rosentiel (eds.), _The New Ethics of Journalism_ (CQ Press, 2013)
  
-*   Brent Baker, "[How to _Identify_ Liberal Media Bias](http://​archive.mrc.org/​books/​identifybias.asp),"​ Media Research Center (1994) 
-*   W. Lance Bennett, Regina G. Lawrence, and Steven Livingston, "​[Press Politics in America: The Case of the Iraq War](http://​www.press.uchicago.edu/​Misc/​Chicago/​042848.html),"​ _When the Press Fails: Political Power and the News Media from Iraq to Katrina_ (University of Chicago Press, 2007) 
  
 ### Business models ### Business models
Line 141: Line 145:
 *   ​Robert W. McChesney, "​[Policing the thinkable](https://​www.opendemocracy.net/​democracy-globalmediaownership/​article_56.jsp),"​ _openDemocracy_ (October 25, 2001) *   ​Robert W. McChesney, "​[Policing the thinkable](https://​www.opendemocracy.net/​democracy-globalmediaownership/​article_56.jsp),"​ _openDemocracy_ (October 25, 2001)
 *   ​Benjamin Compaine, "[The myths of encroaching global media ownership](https://​www.opendemocracy.net/​media-globalmediaownership/​article_87.jsp),"​ _openDemocracy_ (November 8, 2001) *   ​Benjamin Compaine, "[The myths of encroaching global media ownership](https://​www.opendemocracy.net/​media-globalmediaownership/​article_87.jsp),"​ _openDemocracy_ (November 8, 2001)
- 
-And, if you can't get enough, the response to the response: 
- 
-*   ​Robert W. McChesney, "​[Media corporations versus democracy: a response to Benjamin Compaine](https://​www.opendemocracy.net/​media-globalmediaownership/​article_60.jsp),"​ _openDemocracy_ (November 14, 2001) 
  
 Here are some recent reports on the influx of Silicon Valley-style venture capital in new media platforms: Here are some recent reports on the influx of Silicon Valley-style venture capital in new media platforms:
Line 150: Line 150:
 *   ​Adrienne LaFrance, "[Why venture capitalists are suddenly investing in news](http://​qz.com/​186492/​why-venture-capitalists-are-suddenly-investing-in-news/​),"​ _Quartz_ (March 12, 2014) *   ​Adrienne LaFrance, "[Why venture capitalists are suddenly investing in news](http://​qz.com/​186492/​why-venture-capitalists-are-suddenly-investing-in-news/​),"​ _Quartz_ (March 12, 2014)
 *   ​Ricardo Bilton, "[The case against the venture capital craze for content](http://​digiday.com/​publishers/​the-case-against-the-vc-craze-for-content/​),"​ _Digiday_ (March 28, 2014) *   ​Ricardo Bilton, "[The case against the venture capital craze for content](http://​digiday.com/​publishers/​the-case-against-the-vc-craze-for-content/​),"​ _Digiday_ (March 28, 2014)
-*   Noam Scheiber, "​[Gawker Media Employees Vote to Form a Union, and the Bosses Approve](http://​www.nytimes.com/​2015/​06/​05/​business/​gawker-media-employees-vote-to-form-a-union-and-the-bosses-approve.html),"​ _The New York Times_ (June 4, 2015) 
  
-And even one of the country'​s oldest magazines was relying on exploitation:​+Do media makers need to organize?
  
 +*   Noam Scheiber, "​[Gawker Media Employees Vote to Form a Union, and the Bosses Approve](http://​www.nytimes.com/​2015/​06/​05/​business/​gawker-media-employees-vote-to-form-a-union-and-the-bosses-approve.html),"​ _The New York Times_ (June 4, 2015)
 *   Blair Hickman, "​[Nation Institute to Pay Interns Minimum Wage](https://​www.propublica.org/​article/​nation-institute-to-pay-interns-minimum-wage),"​ _Pro Publica_ (August 2, 2013) *   Blair Hickman, "​[Nation Institute to Pay Interns Minimum Wage](https://​www.propublica.org/​article/​nation-institute-to-pay-interns-minimum-wage),"​ _Pro Publica_ (August 2, 2013)
 +
  
 ### The commons ### The commons
Line 160: Line 161:
 Are you a commoner? Here are some general readings on what the commons is all about: Are you a commoner? Here are some general readings on what the commons is all about:
  
-  Fran Korten, "[No Panaceas! Elinor Ostrom Talks with Fran Korten](http://​www.shareable.net/​blog/​no-panaceas-a-qa-with-elinor-ostrom),"​ _Shareable_ (March 18, 2010) +  ​Fran Korten, "[No Panaceas! Elinor Ostrom Talks with Fran Korten](http://​www.shareable.net/​blog/​no-panaceas-a-qa-with-elinor-ostrom),"​ _Shareable_ (March 18, 2010) 
-  ​Jeremy Adam Smith, "[How to Design the Commons (or, Elinor Ostrom Explained!)](http://​www.shareable.net/​blog/​how-to-design-the-commons),"​ _Shareable_ (December 10, 2009)+  * Jeremy Adam Smith, "[How to Design the Commons (or, Elinor Ostrom Explained!)](http://​www.shareable.net/​blog/​how-to-design-the-commons),"​ _Shareable_ (December 10, 2009)
  
 Media commons: Media commons:
  
-  Daniel B. Smith, "[What Is Art For?​](http://​www.nytimes.com/​2008/​11/​16/​magazine/​16hyde-t.html?​pagewanted=all&​_r=0)"​ _The New York Times Magazine_ (November 14, 2008) +  ​Daniel B. Smith, "[What Is Art For?​](http://​www.nytimes.com/​2008/​11/​16/​magazine/​16hyde-t.html?​pagewanted=all&​_r=0)"​ _The New York Times Magazine_ (November 14, 2008) 
-  ​David Bollier, "​Introduction"​ and "​Inventing the Creative Commons,"​ in _[](http://​www.viralspiral.cc/​download-book)_[Viral Spiral: How the Commoners Built a Digital Republic of Their Own](http://​www.viralspiral.cc/​sites/​default/​files/​ViralSpiral.pdf)__ (New Press, 2008) +  * David Bollier, "​Introduction"​ and "​Inventing the Creative Commons,"​ in _[](http://​www.viralspiral.cc/​download-book)_[Viral Spiral: How the Commoners Built a Digital Republic of Their Own](http://​www.viralspiral.cc/​sites/​default/​files/​ViralSpiral.pdf)__ (New Press, 2008) 
-  ​Christopher S. Yoo and Timothy Wu, "​[Keeping the Internet Neutral?​](http://​www.legalaffairs.org/​webexclusive/​dc_printerfriendly.msp?​id=86)"​ _Legal Affairs_ (May 1, 2006)+  * Christopher S. Yoo and Timothy Wu, "​[Keeping the Internet Neutral?​](http://​www.legalaffairs.org/​webexclusive/​dc_printerfriendly.msp?​id=86)"​ _Legal Affairs_ (May 1, 2006)
  
 Finally, silence: Finally, silence:
  
-  Ivan Illich, "​[Silence Is a Commons](http://​www.preservenet.com/​theory/​Illich/​Silence.html),"​ _The CoEvolution Quarterly_ (Winter 1983)+  ​Ivan Illich, "​[Silence Is a Commons](http://​www.preservenet.com/​theory/​Illich/​Silence.html),"​ _The CoEvolution Quarterly_ (Winter 1983) 
  
 ### Filters and bubbles ### Filters and bubbles
Line 177: Line 179:
 Explore some of the debates about "​filter bubbles"​ online. Explore some of the debates about "​filter bubbles"​ online.
  
-  Cass Sunstein et al., "[Is the Internet Bad for Democracy?​](https://​www.bostonreview.net/​forum/​cass-sunstein-internet-bad-democracy)"​ _Boston Review_ (June 2001) +  ​Cass Sunstein et al., "[Is the Internet Bad for Democracy?​](https://​www.bostonreview.net/​forum/​cass-sunstein-internet-bad-democracy)"​ _Boston Review_ (June 2001) 
-  ​Eli Pariser, "​[Beware Online '​Filter Bubbles](http://​www.ted.com/​talks/​eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_bubbles),'"​ TED Talk (March 2011) +  * Eli Pariser, "​[Beware Online '​Filter Bubbles](http://​www.ted.com/​talks/​eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_bubbles),'"​ TED Talk (March 2011) 
-  ​nina de jesus, "[The Filter Bubble Is a Misguided, Privileged Notion](http://​geekfeminism.org/​2014/​02/​27/​the-filter-bubble-is-a-misguided-privileged-notion/​),"​ _Geek Feminism_ (February 27, 2014) +  * nina de jesus, "[The Filter Bubble Is a Misguided, Privileged Notion](http://​geekfeminism.org/​2014/​02/​27/​the-filter-bubble-is-a-misguided-privileged-notion/​),"​ _Geek Feminism_ (February 27, 2014) 
-  ​Margaret Weigel, "​[Ideological segregation online and offline](http://​journalistsresource.org/​studies/​society/​news-media/​ideological-segregation-online-and-offline),"​ _Journalist'​s Resource_ (January 10, 2012)+  * Margaret Weigel, "​[Ideological segregation online and offline](http://​journalistsresource.org/​studies/​society/​news-media/​ideological-segregation-online-and-offline),"​ _Journalist'​s Resource_ (January 10, 2012
 +  * Brent Baker, "[How to _Identify_ Liberal Media Bias](http://​archive.mrc.org/​books/​identifybias.asp),"​ Media Research Center (1994)
  
 And that was before (at least so far as we know) Facebook got into experimenting on us with our news feeds... And that was before (at least so far as we know) Facebook got into experimenting on us with our news feeds...
  
-  Vindu Goel, "​[Facebook Tinkers With Users’ Emotions in News Feed Experiment, Stirring Outcry](http://​www.nytimes.com/​2014/​06/​30/​technology/​facebook-tinkers-with-users-emotions-in-news-feed-experiment-stirring-outcry.html),"​ _The New York Times_ (June 2, 2014)+  ​Vindu Goel, "​[Facebook Tinkers With Users’ Emotions in News Feed Experiment, Stirring Outcry](http://​www.nytimes.com/​2014/​06/​30/​technology/​facebook-tinkers-with-users-emotions-in-news-feed-experiment-stirring-outcry.html),"​ _The New York Times_ (June 2, 2014)
  
-...and replacing news platforms altogether.+Maybe we should be more careful with which search engines we use:
  
-  ​Claire Cain Miller, "[Why Facebook’s News Experiment Matters to Readers](http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/15/​upshot/​how-facebooks-experiment-changes-the-news-and-how-it-doesnt.html)," ​_The New York Times_ ​(May 14, 2015) +  ​* Frank Pasquale, "[Dominant Search Engines: An Essential Cultural & Political Facility](http://digitalcommons.law.umaryland.edu/fac_pubs/1359/)," in Szoka, Berin and Marcus, Adam, eds., _The Next Digital Decade: Essays on the Future of the Internet_ ​(2010). 
- +  John Paul Titlow, "[Inside DuckDuckGo, Google'​s Tiniest, Fiercest Competitor](https://www.fastcompany.com/3026698/inside-duckduckgo-googles-tiniest-fiercest-competitor)," ​_Fast Company_ ​(February 202014)
-But no big deal+
- +
-  Rachel Metz, "[Facebook Says You Filter News More Than Its Algorithm Does](http://www.technologyreview.com/news/537216/​facebook-says-you-filter-news-more-than-its-algorithm-does/​)," ​_MIT Technology Review_ ​(May 72015) +
- +
-Maybe we should be more careful with which search engines we use:+
  
-*   Frank Pasquale, "​[Dominant Search Engines: An Essential Cultural & Political Facility](http://​digitalcommons.law.umaryland.edu/​fac_pubs/​1359/​),"​ in Szoka, Berin and Marcus, Adam, eds., _The Next Digital Decade: Essays on the Future of the Internet_ (2010). 
-*   John Paul Titlow, "​[Inside DuckDuckGo, Google'​s Tiniest, Fiercest Competitor](https://​www.fastcompany.com/​3026698/​inside-duckduckgo-googles-tiniest-fiercest-competitor),"​ _Fast Company_ (February 20, 2014) 
  
 ### Making movements ### Making movements
Line 219: Line 215:
  
 *   ​Gabriella Coleman, "​[Indymedia'​s Independence:​ From Activist Media to Free Software](http://​autonomousuniversity.org/​sites/​default/​files/​Biella_Coleman-Indymedia%27s-Independence.pdf)"​ *   ​Gabriella Coleman, "​[Indymedia'​s Independence:​ From Activist Media to Free Software](http://​autonomousuniversity.org/​sites/​default/​files/​Biella_Coleman-Indymedia%27s-Independence.pdf)"​
 +
  
 ### Leaks, repression, censorship ### Leaks, repression, censorship
Line 227: Line 224:
 What makes speech dangerous? What makes speech dangerous?
  
-  "​[World press freedom index 2014](https://​rsf.org/​index2014/​en-index2014.php#​),"​ Reporters Without Borders (Be sure to click "read more" to access the whole summary) +  ​"​[World press freedom index 2014](https://​rsf.org/​index2014/​en-index2014.php#​),"​ Reporters Without Borders (Be sure to click "read more" to access the whole summary) 
-  ​Yochai Benkler, “[A Free Irresponsible Press: WikiLeaks and the Battle Over the Soul of the Fourth Estate](http://​dash.harvard.edu/​bitstream/​handle/​1/​10900863/​Benkler.pdf?​sequence=1),​” _Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review_ 46 (2011) +  * Yochai Benkler, “[A Free Irresponsible Press: WikiLeaks and the Battle Over the Soul of the Fourth Estate](http://​dash.harvard.edu/​bitstream/​handle/​1/​10900863/​Benkler.pdf?​sequence=1),​” _Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review_ 46 (2011) 
- +   ​* _[The Internet'​s Own Boy: The Story of Aaron Swartz](https://​archive.org/​details/​TheInternetsOwnBoyTheStoryOfAaronSwartz)_ (2014)
-The fate of Internet freedom: +
- +
-  Film:_ [The Internet'​s Own Boy: The Story of Aaron Swartz](https://​archive.org/​details/​TheInternetsOwnBoyTheStoryOfAaronSwartz)_ (2014+
-*   ​Jennifer Stisa Granick, "[The End of the Internet Dream](https://​medium.com/​backchannel/​the-end-of-the-internet-dream-ba060b17da61),"​ _Backchannel_ (August 17, 2015)+
  
  
 ### Public intellectualism ### Public intellectualism
  
-*   Wendy Kaminer, "[The End of Free Speech at University of Colorado?​](http://​www.theatlantic.com/​national/​archive/​2012/​09/​the-end-of-free-speech-at-university-of-colorado/​262494/​)"​ _The Atlantic_ (September 18, 2012) 
 *   Dane S. Claussen, "[A Brief History of Anti-Intellectualism in American Media](http://​www.aaup.org/​article/​brief-history-anti-intellectualism-american-media),"​ _Academe_ (May-June 2011) *   Dane S. Claussen, "[A Brief History of Anti-Intellectualism in American Media](http://​www.aaup.org/​article/​brief-history-anti-intellectualism-american-media),"​ _Academe_ (May-June 2011)
 *   Alan Lightman, "[The Role of the Public Intellectual](http://​web.mit.edu/​comm-forum/​papers/​lightman.html),"​ _MIT Communications Forum_ *   Alan Lightman, "[The Role of the Public Intellectual](http://​web.mit.edu/​comm-forum/​papers/​lightman.html),"​ _MIT Communications Forum_
 *   ​Michael Eric Dyson, "​[Think Out Loud](http://​www.newrepublic.com/​article/​122756/​think-out-loud-emerging-black-digital-intelligentsia),"​ _The New Republic_ (September 9, 2015) *   ​Michael Eric Dyson, "​[Think Out Loud](http://​www.newrepublic.com/​article/​122756/​think-out-loud-emerging-black-digital-intelligentsia),"​ _The New Republic_ (September 9, 2015)
 *   ​Evette Brown, "[Why Do We Have More Female Scholars, But Few Public Intellectuals?​](https://​bitchmedia.org/​post/​why-do-we-have-more-female-scholars-but-few-public-intellectuals)"​ _Bitch Media_ (July 8, 2013) *   ​Evette Brown, "[Why Do We Have More Female Scholars, But Few Public Intellectuals?​](https://​bitchmedia.org/​post/​why-do-we-have-more-female-scholars-but-few-public-intellectuals)"​ _Bitch Media_ (July 8, 2013)
-*   Nicholas Kristof, "[Professors, We Need You!](http://​www.nytimes.com/2014/02/16/opinion/sunday/​kristof-professors-we-need-you.html)" _The New York Times_ ​(February 152014)+*   Wendy Kaminer, "[The End of Free Speech at University of Colorado?](http://​www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/09/the-end-of-free-speech-at-university-of-colorado/​262494/​)"​ _The Atlantic_ (September 18, 2012) 
 +*   Corey Robin, "[How Intellectuals Create a Public](http://​chronicle.com/​article/​How-Intellectuals-Create-a/​234984)," _The Chronicle of Higher Education_ ​(January 222015) 
  
 ### Harassment, abuse, accountability ### Harassment, abuse, accountability
Line 250: Line 244:
  
 *   ​Jonathan Chait, "[Not a Very P.C. Thing to Say](http://​nymag.com/​daily/​intelligencer/​2015/​01/​not-a-very-pc-thing-to-say.html),"​ _New York_ (January 27, 2015) *   ​Jonathan Chait, "[Not a Very P.C. Thing to Say](http://​nymag.com/​daily/​intelligencer/​2015/​01/​not-a-very-pc-thing-to-say.html),"​ _New York_ (January 27, 2015)
- 
-*   ​Lindsay Beyerstein, "​[‘New York’ Mag Writer Is Incorrect on Political Correctness](http://​observer.com/​2015/​01/​jonathan-chait-vs-political-correctness/​),"​ _Observer_ (January 28, 2015) 
- 
 *   Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt, "[The Coddling of the American Mind](http://​www.theatlantic.com/​magazine/​archive/​2015/​09/​the-coddling-of-the-american-mind/​399356/​),"​ _The Atlantic_ (September 2015) *   Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt, "[The Coddling of the American Mind](http://​www.theatlantic.com/​magazine/​archive/​2015/​09/​the-coddling-of-the-american-mind/​399356/​),"​ _The Atlantic_ (September 2015)
 *   Joan Wallach Scott, "[The Campaign Against Political Correctness:​ What’s Really at Stake](http://​rhr.dukejournals.org/​content/​1992/​54/​59.full.pdf),"​ _Radical History Review_ 54 (1992) *   Joan Wallach Scott, "[The Campaign Against Political Correctness:​ What’s Really at Stake](http://​rhr.dukejournals.org/​content/​1992/​54/​59.full.pdf),"​ _Radical History Review_ 54 (1992)