Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
peer_review [2021/01/05 19:45]
ntnsndr
peer_review [2022/03/30 15:47] (current)
ntnsndr
Line 8: Line 8:
  
   * How would you summarize what the creator is trying to accomplish in the draft? Reflect that back to make sure your reading matches the creator'​s intent.   * How would you summarize what the creator is trying to accomplish in the draft? Reflect that back to make sure your reading matches the creator'​s intent.
 +  * What do you think is working best about the draft? Choose some specific features that any revision should be sure to build on.
   * What kind of revision should the creator focus on? Are high-level, structural changes necessary, or should the creator focus more on smaller-scale adjustments?​ Pick one of these to focus on, and indicate to the creator why you're making that choice.   * What kind of revision should the creator focus on? Are high-level, structural changes necessary, or should the creator focus more on smaller-scale adjustments?​ Pick one of these to focus on, and indicate to the creator why you're making that choice.
   * What audience do you think the creator aiming to reach, and to what effect? What choices help or hinder persuading that audience? How well does the draft accord with the rules or norms of the relevant genre?   * What audience do you think the creator aiming to reach, and to what effect? What choices help or hinder persuading that audience? How well does the draft accord with the rules or norms of the relevant genre?
-  * What do you think is working best about the draft? Choose some specific features that any revision should be sure to build on. 
   * Where would you recommend focusing revision efforts? What are the highest priority concerns, in your view?   * Where would you recommend focusing revision efforts? What are the highest priority concerns, in your view?
   * What are some concerns that are smaller, but that should nevertheless be considered?   * What are some concerns that are smaller, but that should nevertheless be considered?